The first Green Paper on transport poverty in Italy: a phenomenon of vulnerability affecting 7 million Italians

In Italy, more than 7 million people live in conditions of “transport poverty”, a form of social vulnerability that is still little known and that takes the form of an inability to afford the costs of public or private transport and of a lack of, or limited access to, the transport needed to reach essential services, work and economic and social opportunities. The figure emerges from the first Green Paper on transport poverty in Italy, presented today by the Transport Poverty Lab promoted by the Fondazione per lo Sviluppo Sostenibile, with our support and that of Tper, under the patronage of the European Commission, the Ministero dell’Ambiente e della Sicurezza Energetica and the Ministero delle Infrastrutture e dei Trasporti, and with the technical collaboration of the Osservatorio Sharing Mobility and of the Fondazione Transform Transport ETS. According to the study, around 1.2 million households are simultaneously at risk of poverty and bear particularly high mobility costs. At the same time, 7.3 million citizens live in areas with insufficient public transport provision. The territorial gap is marked: in the South, the availability of local public transport falls below 200 seat-km per inhabitant in some areas of Sardinia and Sicily, against a national average of 4,623 and more than 16,000 seat-km recorded in Milan. At regional level, the highest share of vulnerable households is found in Calabria, where it exceeds 10%, while the figure falls below 2% in Trentino-Alto Adige. The 4 types of vulnerable citizens The Green Paper has developed a first transport poverty matrix that identifies 4 macro-types of citizens, as an interpretative key to the phenomenon, in which the two main components often overlap — the difficulty of bearing mobility costs and the difficulty of accessing the transport needed to reach opportunities and essential services:
- Absolute vulnerability: Citizens subject to the most acute form of exclusion, where low income is compounded by the absence of available transport options in the area;
- Territorial vulnerability: Citizens with adequate personal resources, but penalised by a territorial context poor in mobility services. They often compensate for these limits by relying heavily on the private car ;
- Personal vulnerability: Citizens living in a well-served area, but with limited personal capacities. Economic, physical or social barriers reduce their ability to use the services ;
- Availability and accessibility: Citizens with adequate personal capacities, in an area that offers multiple efficient mobility options .
The European Regulation establishing the Social Climate Fund adds to this “structural” vulnerability an “induced vulnerability” that occurs when a European measure designed to promote sustainable mobility has an economic impact on citizens and micro-enterprises. To counter it, the Fund mobilises around 85 billion euro, to be used over the period 2026-2032, of which 9 are allocated to Italy. How to tackle transport poverty – a ten-point list In Europe, more than 25 million residents are unable to buy a car, more than 10 million lack the financial resources to use public transport and almost 90 million do not have access to an accessible public transport offer. To tackle transport poverty, the European Regulation identifies two macro-categories in which Member States can invest to mitigate the social and economic impact on vulnerable users and micro-enterprises: 1. Facilitating access to zero- and low-emission vehicles. 2. Facilitating access to shared and sustainable mobility. In particular, by proposing a first operational taxonomy, the Guidance on the Social Climate Plans offers a genuine ten-point list of measures to address this phenomenon:
- Financial support and tax incentives for the direct purchase of low- and zero-emission vehicles; 2. Schemes for the rental or leasing of zero-emission vehicles for vulnerable groups based on income, public transport accessibility, and time and distance between home and workplace; 3. Investment in smart, bidirectional public charging infrastructure at competitive prices, in areas with vulnerable users; 4. Subsidies for the purchase or leasing of zero-emission vehicles intended for micro-enterprises (taxis, vans, trucks, special-purpose vehicles or cargo bikes); 5. Additional bonuses for the scrapping of diesel and petrol vehicles, with a guarantee that polluting replacement vehicles are not purchased; 6. Promotion of the use of bicycles, e-bikes, cargo bikes and micromobility solutions, encouraging the creation of safe cycling infrastructure connecting low-income areas with key destinations, and subsidies for the purchase, long-term rental or leasing of bicycles, e-bikes or cargo bikes; 7. Incentives for the use of affordable and accessible public transport, supporting public and private bodies, including cooperatives, in developing sustainable on-demand mobility, shared mobility and active mobility options; 8. Public support for on-demand services, “mobility as a service (MaaS)” and sharing mobility, to cover the entire journey chain, including the first and last mile, taking into account the needs of vulnerable groups in remote and disadvantaged areas, including through subsidised vouchers; 9. Extension of the public transport offer and of related infrastructure, especially in rural and underserved urban areas, benefiting vulnerable transport users; 10. Investment in mobility hubs, to facilitate interchange and connections between public transport, shared mobility, cycling and walking in suburban, peri-urban and rural areas.
“Promoting and supporting mobility as a decisive factor in the quality of life of every individual is a key objective on the path towards fairness and equal opportunities for citizens. Nordcom, a company that offers digital solutions in transport, has supported from the outset the Laboratory for analysis and study dedicated to transport poverty in Italy. Digital tools, technological innovation and artificial intelligence are all enabling levers for tackling transport poverty. The first Report, which we are presenting today in Milan, clearly shows the importance of complementing strategic and system-wide choices with adequate digital planning, which is essential to achieving the objectives set out in the Report” states Fabrizio Garavaglia (Chairman of Nordcom) For further insight into transport poverty, we invite you to read the three Green Papers published on our LinkedIn profile: CONSIDER: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7445050737312714754 UNDERSTAND: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7445374348267438080 TACKLE: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7445468208402419712